bayu-aji
The administration of President Donald Trump has introduced a major plan to reshape how the United States conducts its decennial census, presenting a federal proposal that would omit specific groups of noncitizens from the country’s official population tallies.
Under the framework published by the Department of Commerce on Wednesday, only United States citizens and lawful permanent residents would be counted in the official census tally. Other noncitizens residing in the country would be barred from inclusion in the primary count.
The exclusion would apply broadly to individuals living in the United States without legal documentation as well as foreign nationals residing in the country under temporary legal status. This would mark a significant shift in how the federal government measures the nation’s populace every ten years.
In justifying the policy change, the administration argued in its proposal that undocumented residents and foreign nationals who do not possess permanent legal status cannot be considered "true inhabitants" of the nation. The document asserted that such individuals do not have a sufficient "tie and allegiance" to the United States to warrant inclusion.
This proposed standard represents a sharp break from centuries of established historical precedent. Since the passage of the 1790 Census Act, federal census workers have been directed to enumerate every person residing at a "usual place of abode" across the country, regardless of their nationality or legal status.
The decennial census serves as the foundational benchmark for key mechanisms of American governance, directly dictating how political power and federal resources are distributed across states and local municipalities. The resulting data determines the reapportionment of seats in the US House of Representatives.
Beyond its political implications for congressional representation, census data plays a central role in the formulas used to distribute federal funding. According to figures from the US Census Bureau, census metrics were used to direct more than $2.8 trillion in federal assistance during fiscal year 2021 alone.
Alongside changing which residents are counted, the Commerce Department proposal advocates for removing specific questions regarding race and ethnicity from the census questionnaire. The administration expressed skepticism about the ongoing utility of these inquiries, citing doubts regarding their meaning, significance, and overall impact.
The proposal argued that eliminating these demographic questions would lessen the burden on households filling out the mandatory ten-year survey. Federal officials maintained that simplifying the form would boost overall response rates and allow the Census Bureau to gather more complete direct data, which the document claimed would lead to fairer political representation.
To enforce the proposed citizenship boundaries, the administration also plans to add new inquiries about legal immigration status to the census short-form questionnaire. While submitting false information on a census document is already categorized as a federal crime, the proposal outlines aggressive new verification measures.
Under these proposed enforcement mechanisms, the government would cross-reference citizenship declarations against administrative databases across other agencies, including records maintained by the Department of Homeland Security and the Department of the Treasury, which houses the Internal Revenue Service.
The initiative revives previous efforts by Trump during his first presidential term to implement citizenship inquiries on the 2020 census. That earlier attempt was ultimately struck down by the US Supreme Court in 2019 after the justices concluded that the administration’s stated rationale for adding the question appeared "contrived."
Civil rights advocates and policy critics have raised sharp concerns over the new proposal, warning that the collection and cross-referencing of immigration data could be weaponized to advance the administration’s promised mass deportation campaign. Opponents also warn that the move will intimidate immigrant households, depressing participation and skewing vital demographic data needed for local public services.
William Frey, a demographer at the Brookings Institution, warned that the scope of the proposal extends far beyond technical survey mechanics. Frey stated that the administration is seeking to redefine the fundamental concept of who counts as an American, while cautioning that the rhetoric alone could deter vulnerable communities from taking part in civic counts.
Frey emphasized that even if the proposal is blocked in court or fails to be enacted, the mere threat of enforcement creates a damaging chilling effect that discourages noncitizens and mixed-status families from engaging with government surveys.
The census overhaul is part of a broader series of White House initiatives capable of altering the American electoral landscape, arriving alongside administrative pushes concerning congressional redistricting and stricter rules surrounding mail-in voting. Tensions over immigration data have also escalated elsewhere, with the Department of Justice warning on September 2 that states risk forfeiting billions of dollars in welfare assistance if local agencies do not report undocumented immigrants. The US Census Bureau did not respond to requests for comment regarding the proposal.
Comments (0)