indah-permata
Video assistant referee Matt Donohue and assistant VAR Blake Antrobus have been stood down from officiating duty for the upcoming weekend of Premier League fixtures following a high-profile misjudgment in the Manchester derby. The disciplinary response follows intense scrutiny surrounding a contentious goal that determined the final outcome of the fiercely contested match between Manchester City and Manchester United.
The decisive action to remove both officials from the upcoming matchweek appointments was confirmed by chief refereeing officer Howard Webb alongside his executive management team. Pro Ref, the governing organization overseeing elite officiating in English professional football, stepped in after determining that the video review team made an undeniable error in their interpretation of a key offside incident.
Under the measures enacted by Webb and the refereeing leadership group, neither Donohue nor Antrobus has received an assignment for any fixture in the upcoming round of English top-flight football. The disciplinary stand-down is expected to remain in effect for an extended duration, with neither official anticipated to return to matchday responsibilities until after the international break.
The controversial sequence that prompted the administrative intervention unfolded during Manchester City’s narrow 1-0 victory over Manchester United. Striker Erling Haaland converted a crucial opportunity during the second half of the encounter, delivering what proved to be the match-winning goal that secured all three points for the visiting side in the cross-town rivalry.
Immediately following the play on the pitch, the on-field match officials intervened by initially disallowing Haaland's conversion due to an offside infraction. The initial decision made by the officiating crew on the grass was to wave off the goal, momentarily keeping the score level between the two clubs while the play was subject to video verification.
However, the subsequent analysis conducted inside the video operations room led to a reversal of the on-field call. After examining the video angles of the play, Donohue and Antrobus concentrated on Haaland's specific position, coming to the conclusion that the Norwegian forward was legally onside at the exact moment the attacking pass was delivered.
Guided by that assessment, the video assistant referee communicated with the on-field referee to overturn the original offside ruling, thereby validating Haaland’s strike and awarding Manchester City the winning goal. The decision immediately generated significant debate, leading Pro Ref to conduct an immediate review of how the review room handled the entire sequence of events.
Following its internal post-match evaluation, the refereeing body issued a formal statement openly acknowledging that the VAR team had committed a critical error by allowing the decisive goal to stand. Pro Ref acknowledged that the technical officiating team had failed to properly apply the laws of the game during their on-screen assessment.
The governing body explained that the primary oversight made by Donohue and Antrobus was a failure to account for the actions of Manchester City midfielder Enzo Fernandez. Although Haaland was judged to be in an onside position, Fernandez was situated in a clear offside position as the attacking passage unfolded across the penalty area.
According to the established laws of football, an attacking player who is in an offside position must be penalized if they attempt to play the ball or clearly impact the defensive play. Pro Ref confirmed that because Fernandez actively attempted to play the ball from an illegal position, the goal should have been ruled out for offside.
The fallout from the misapplication of the rules has significant sporting implications for Manchester United, whose challenging domestic campaign suffered a damaging blow as a result of the 1-0 defeat. Following the derby loss, United remain stalled in 13th place in the Premier League table, facing an uphill battle to recover ground in the domestic standings.
Manchester United will attempt to rebound from the contentious league defeat as they turn their focus toward a busy fixture schedule. The club is set to host Brighton in the League Cup on Wednesday evening before traveling to face Fulham on Sunday afternoon in their next Premier League contest.
In contrast, the awarded goal allowed Manchester City to maintain their pursuit at the top of the English top division. The three points collected in the derby leave City level on points with league leaders and defending champions Arsenal, keeping the reigning champions in close contention at the summit of the league table.
Manchester City must also navigate a quick turnaround across multiple domestic competitions over the coming days. The team is scheduled to host Norwich City in a League Cup fixture on Thursday before returning to Premier League action on Sunday, when they will entertain Sunderland in a home league match.
The decision to stand down both Donohue and Antrobus reflects the strict standard of operational accountability enforced by Howard Webb and the leadership at Pro Ref. By removing officials responsible for major review errors from high-stakes matches, the organization aims to rebuild confidence in video officiating technology and minimize high-profile disruptions across the Premier League season.
Comments (0)